Frequently Asked Questions

Are The Pet Pantry’s foods safe and tested?
Yes! Every batch is slow-cooked in small quantities to preserve nutrients and is rigorously tested for safety and nutrition. We’re proud of our spotless recall record
At what age should I spay or neuter my dog or cat?
Most veterinarians recommend spaying or neutering pets around 6 months of age, but the ideal timing can vary depending on breed, size, and health. Always consult your vet to determine the best age for your pet.
Can I get free samples of dog food before buying a full bag?
Yes! The Pet Pantry offers free dog food samples delivered to your door so you can test recipes and find the best fit for your dog’s taste and dietary needs.
Can I get both dog and cat food samples?
Yes. If you have multiple pets, you can request dog and cat food samples in the same order, making it easy to find the right fit for your whole family of pets.
Can I get recommendations while shopping if I’m not sure what to buy?
Of course! If you’re unsure, our team provides personalized shopping guidance—helping you choose the right food for allergies, sensitivities, weight management, puppies, seniors, and more.
Can I shop for specialty dog food, like weight control or sensitive stomach formulas?
Absolutely. Our selection includes weight management recipes, skin & coat support, and allergy-friendly options, including both Holistic Choice and other carefully selected brands.
Can The Pet Pantry help me choose the right food for my pet?
Absolutely. Whether your pet has allergies, weight issues, or is a picky eater, our team provides personalized recommendations to make sure every meal supports your pet’s health.
Do free samples include treats or just food?
Currently, free samples focus on our Holistic Choice dry food recipes, but we occasionally include treats or promotions. Keep an eye on our site for seasonal offers.
Do grain-free diets cause Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs?
In 2018, the FDA began investigating reports of DCM in dogs eating certain grain-free foods, particularly those high in legumes like peas, lentils, or chickpeas. No evidence has been found linking grain-free foods and DCM in dogs.
Do Holistic Choice recipes support long-term health better than mainstream foods?
Yes! Our small-batch, slow-cooked recipes lock in vital nutrients that support immune health, digestion, joint care, and long-term vitality. Unlike many mainstream foods that cut corners for cost efficiency, Holistic Choice ensures your pet gets the full benefits of real, nutrient-rich nutrition.
Do you carry dog treats and chews in addition to food?
Yes! The Pet Pantry shop includes healthy dog treats, chews, and snacks made with natural ingredients. We focus on offering options that are both delicious and supportive of your dog’s overall health.
Do you offer grain-free and grain-inclusive options in your shop?
Absolutely. Whether your pet thrives on a grain-free diet or prefers wholesome grains like brown rice, our Holistic Choice recipes and partner brands cover both options, making it simple to shop based on your pet’s needs.
Do you only sell The Pet Pantry’s Holistic Choice, or other brands too?
While we specialize in our Holistic Choice brand, you can also shop from a selection of trusted national brands for food, treats, and toys, giving you the best mix of premium, health-focused options.
Holistic Choice vs Farmer’s Dog: Which is more convenient and cost-effective?
Farmer’s Dog offers fresh-frozen meals, but they require freezer space, thawing time, and come with a hefty price tag. Holistic Choice delivers the same premium nutrition in a shelf-stable kibble that’s simple to store, scoop, and serve—without the mess or extra cost. For many pet parents, it’s the smarter balance of top-quality nutrition and everyday convenience.
Holistic Choice vs Fresh Pet: What’s the nutritional advantage?
Fresh Pet promotes itself as a fresh option, but with its high moisture content and need for refrigeration, it comes with a shorter shelf life and a higher cost per meal. Holistic Choice kibble is nutrient-dense, highly digestible, and shelf-stable, giving your pet the benefits of fresh, wholesome ingredients—without the hassle.
Holistic Choice vs Grocery Store Brands: Is it worth paying more?
Yes! Grocery store brands like Purina Dog Chow or Iams often rely on fillers, by-products, and artificial preservatives to cut costs. Holistic Choice leaves out the cheap stuff and packs in premium nutrition with every bite. That means you feed less, see better results, and often save on vet bills in the long run.
Holistic Choice vs Iams: Which is healthier for my pet?
Holistic Choice is slow-cooked in small batches with clean, USA-sourced ingredients to preserve nutrients and maximize health benefits. While Iams may be convenient and affordable, it often relies on by-products, fillers, and artificial additives. With Holistic Choice, you’re giving your pet a nutrient-dense diet focused on long-term health—not just short-term convenience.
Holistic Choice vs Purina: What’s the difference?
Holistic Choice is made with human-quality proteins, whole grains, and natural vitamins—never by-products, fillers, or artificial preservatives. By contrast, brands like Purina often rely on meat by-products, corn, wheat, and soy as main ingredients. Pet parents who make the switch to Holistic Choice typically notice better digestion, shinier coats, and fewer allergy concerns in their pets.
How do I know if the food I’ve chosen is working well for my dog/cat?
Your pet will show you through their overall health and happiness! Signs that a food is a good fit include: Healthy skin & shiny coat – soft fur with less shedding or dandruff. Good digestion – regular, firm stools without excessive gas or tummy upset. Steady energy & vitality – active, playful, and maintaining a healthy weight. Bright eyes & strong immune health – fewer illnesses and quicker recovery. If you notice persistent issues like itching, frequent stomach upset, dull coat, or lack of energy, it may be time to adjust their diet.
How do I know which recipe is best for my pet?
Each of our recipes is formulated by small-animal nutritionists and veterinarians to support different life stages, breed sizes, and health needs. If you’re unsure which recipe is right, just reach out to us. Our team loves helping pet parents find the paw-fect match for their furry family members
How do I properly store my food for optimal freshness?
"To keep your pet’s food fresh and nutritious, follow these simple tips: 1. Keep it sealed – Store food in its original bag or airtight container. 2. Store in a cool, dry place – Avoid heat, humidity, or direct sunlight, which can cause nutrients to break down faster. 3. Do not pour new food on top of old food in the container and be sure to wash scoops and food bowls regularly."
How do I transition properly from one food to another?
To avoid digestive upset, it’s best to transition your pet’s food gradually over 5–7 days: Days 1–2: 75% old food, 25% new food, Days 3-4: 50% old food, 50% new food, Days 5-6: 25% old food, 75% new food, Day 7: 100% new food. Watch your pet’s stool and overall behavior during the transition. If you notice loose stools or tummy upset, slow the process down and give your pet more time to adjust.
How do pets respond to Holistic Choice compared to foods like Purina or Iams?
Pets on Holistic Choice often enjoy better digestion, shinier coats, healthier teeth and gums, and more energy. Many pet parents come to us after dealing with allergies, skin troubles, or picky eating from mass-market foods—and they quickly see the difference. A happier, healthier pet is what Holistic Choice is all about!
How is Holistic Choice pet food made?
Holistic Choice is made with care from start to finish. We start by selecting human-quality proteins, wholesome grains, and farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, all sourced in the USA. Each recipe is then slow-cooked in small batches at lower temperatures to preserve nutrients, flavor, and digestibility. Finally, every batch is tested for safety and quality before it ever reaches your pet’s bowl. This makes a nutrient-dense food that supports better digestion, a stronger immune system, shiny coats, and long-term vitality.
How long will it take for my dog to reach a healthy weight?
Every dog is different, but with the right food and activity, many see improvements in energy, mobility, and weight within the first month. Slow and steady weight loss is the healthiest path, helping your dog keep the pounds off long-term.
How many cups of food are in a 20 lb. bag?
There are approximately 80 cups of food in a 20 lb. bag. This will vary slightly depending on the kibble size.
How much should I feed my overweight dog?
The Lighten Up Dog program is The Pet Pantry’s weight management initiative that helps pet parents choose the right nutrition, portion sizes, and feeding routines for overweight or less active dogs.
Is Holistic Choice available for puppies, seniors, or pets with special needs?
Yes. Holistic Choice offers tailored solutions for puppies, seniors, weight management, skin & coat health, and pets with allergies, ensuring the right nutrition at every life stage.
Is Holistic Choice better for picky eaters or pets with sensitivities than big brands?
Yes! Since Holistic Choice is made without corn, wheat, soy, or by-products, it’s a great fit for picky eaters, allergy-prone pets, and sensitive stomachs. And with both grain-inclusive and grain-free recipes, you’ve got the flexibility to choose the diet that best supports your pet’s unique needs.
Is Holistic Choice more affordable than Purina or Iams in the long run?
Yes! Our pricing is very competitive with Purina and grocery-store, Purina, brands might look cheaper up front, but Holistic Choice is more nutritionally dense—so your pet gets more from every bite and you actually feed less per meal. Plus, with better digestion, healthier skin and coats, and fewer allergy or tummy troubles, many families see fewer vet visits. That adds up to better health and better long-term value compared to brands like Purina or Iams.
Is The Pet Pantry good for puppies and senior dogs?
Yes. We provide age-specific nutrition—puppy food that supports growth and development, and senior recipes designed for joint health, digestion, and overall wellness.
Is your packaging BPA-free?
Yes. All Holistic Choice products are BPA-free.
Should I add vitamins or other supplements on top of their daily food?
For normally healthy pets a supplement/vitamin is not necessary when feeding Holistic Choice foods. If your pet has a specific health issue that needs to be addressed, supplements/vitamins may be a good option to consider. Always consult with your pet's veterinarian for more information on supplements and vitamins.
Should I change my pet’s food occasionally to keep them from getting bored?
Change can be healthy—in moderation. Switching foods too often can lead to picky eating habits and upset tummies. If you’d like to change your pet’s food, we recommend waiting at least 3 months between switches and choosing recipes that aren’t drastically different to reduce the chance of digestive upset. The good news? Most of our Holistic Choice recipes are multi-protein blends, so your pet gets natural variety in every bowl—no constant rotation needed.
What age should I switch my dog from puppy food to adult food?
Most dogs are ready to transition from puppy food to adult food around 12 months of age. Large and giant breeds may benefit from staying on puppy formulas a little longer—up to 18–24 months—since they grow more slowly.
What health benefits can I expect from feeding Holistic Choice?
Pet parents report shinier coats, healthier skin, stronger immune systems, better digestion, improved stool quality, and more consistent energy after switching to Holistic Choice.
What health risks are linked to an overweight dog?
Excess weight increases the risk of diabetes, heart disease, arthritis, joint problems, and reduced lifespan. Helping your dog reach a healthy weight can significantly improve their quality of life and longevity.
What human foods are safe to add to my dog’s food?
Some fresh, whole foods can be a healthy addition to your dog’s diet in moderation. Safe options include: Lean proteins like plain cooked chicken, turkey, or salmon (no seasoning, bones, or skin). Vegetables such as carrots, green beans, pumpkin, or broccoli. Fruits like blueberries, apple slices (without seeds), or bananas. Plain grains like rice or oatmeal (cooked and unseasoned). Healthy extras such as a spoonful of plain pumpkin purée or plain yogurt (no added sugar or artificial sweeteners).
What human foods should I not feed to my dog?
Some foods and additives that are safe for humans can be harmful—or even dangerous—for dogs. Ingredients to avoid include:Chocolate & caffeine – can be toxic to the nervous system and heart. Grapes & raisins – may cause kidney failure. Onions, garlic, chives – damage red blood cells and can cause anemia. Xylitol (artificial sweetener) – found in sugar-free gum, peanut butter, and baked goods; can cause dangerous drops in blood sugar. Alcohol & raw yeast dough – harmful to the liver and digestive system. High-fat or heavily seasoned foods – can upset digestion and may trigger pancreatitis. By-products, artificial colors, and preservatives – offer no nutritional value and may be harsh on sensitive systems. If you feel unsure about a particular food, it is recommended to err on the side of caution and not give the food to your pet.
What if my pet doesn’t like the food?
We stand behind every recipe. If for any reason you or your pet aren’t completely happy, we’ll refund your purchase. No hassles, no worries—just our promise to keep you and your pet satisfied.
What ingredients are used in Holistic Choice recipes?
Holistic Choice recipes are made with the kind of ingredients you can feel good about: real, human-quality proteins, wholesome whole grains, nutritious fruits and vegetables, natural vitamins and minerals to support balanced, complete nutrition. You’ll never find by-products, fillers, corn, wheat, soy, GMOs, or artificial preservatives in our foods. Just clean, USA-sourced goodness crafted in small batches to help your pet thrive with better digestion, shinier coats, and more energy.
What is Holistic Choice pet food?
Holistic Choice is our super-premium pet food, made with human-quality ingredients and slow-cooked in small batches to lock in nutrients. Every recipe is thoughtfully crafted to deliver balanced, wholesome nutrition for both dogs and cats.
What is the Lighten Up Dog program?
The Lighten Up Dog program is The Pet Pantry’s weight management initiative that helps pet parents choose the right nutrition, portion sizes, and feeding routines for overweight or less active dogs.
What makes Holistic Choice different from other pet foods?
Holistic Choice is our own exclusive brand, handcrafted in small batches and slow-cooked at low temperatures right here in the USA. We use only human-grade ingredients with no by-products, fillers, GMOs, or artificial additives—just real, wholesome nutrition you can feel good about. Pets thrive on our recipes, and their humans love the noticeable difference in energy, digestion, skin, coat and overall vitality
What makes Holistic Choice dog food different?
Holistic Choice is made with human-grade proteins, wholesome grains, and natural vitamins and minerals, slow-cooked in small batches to preserve nutrients. Unlike many big brands, it contains no by-products, corn, wheat, soy, fillers, or artificial additives
What makes slow-cooking at lower temperatures better?
Slow-cooking at lower temperatures helps preserve the natural nutrients, flavors, and integrity of each ingredient. Unlike high-heat methods that can break down proteins and vitamins, our gentle process locks in nutrition so your pet gets the full benefits of wholesome, real-food ingredients. It also enhances digestibility and taste, making every meal both healthier and more enjoyable for your pet.
What makes The Pet Pantry different from other pet food companies?
We specialize in premium nutrition with our exclusive Holistic Choice brand and a curated selection of trusted partner products. Plus, our local delivery, personalized service, and 100% satisfaction guarantee set us apart from national chains
What makes The Pet Pantry different from big-box pet stores?
We specialize in premium nutrition with our exclusive Holistic Choice brand and a curated selection of trusted partner products. Plus, our local delivery, personalized service, and 100% satisfaction guarantee set us apart from national chains
Where are Holistic Choice foods made and where do you source ingredients from?
All of our Holistic Choice foods are proudly made in the USA. Our ingredients are carefully sourced from trusted U.S. farmers and suppliers—never overseas. That means you can trust that every bowl is filled with safe, high-quality, wholesome ingredients
Why is my dog overweight and how can I tell if they need to lose weight?
Over 50% of dogs in the U.S. are overweight, often due to overfeeding, high-calorie treats, or lack of exercise. Signs include difficulty feeling ribs, a lack of a waistline, or reduced energy. If you’re unsure, please give us a call and we can help you determine the best steps forward.
Why should I choose Holistic Choice over Farmer’s Dog or other fresh food delivery services?
Fresh subscription brands like Farmer’s Dog may offer quality meals, but they can be pricey, messy, and require precious freezer space. With Holistic Choice, you get the same premium nutrition in a convenient, shelf-stable kibble—no refrigeration needed. It’s easier to store, serve, and budget, all without ever compromising on quality.
Will my dog still enjoy the taste of weight management food?
Yes! Holistic Choice formulas are crafted with ingredients dogs love. Many customers find their dogs eagerly switch from calorie-heavy kibble to our Light recipes without hesitation.
Will my picky eater actually eat it?
Absolutely. We hear it all the time—bowls licked clean! With multiple flavors and proteins to choose from, even the pickiest eaters usually find their favorite. We offer very generous free samples and we’ll work with you to find a recipe they love.
Besides changing food, how else can I help my dog lose weight?
Pair proper nutrition with daily exercise like walks, play sessions, or swimming. Avoid high-calorie table scraps and choose healthy treats in moderation. Consistency is key to safe, steady weight loss.
Are The Pet Pantry’s foods safe and tested?
Yes! Every batch is slow-cooked in small quantities to preserve nutrients and is rigorously tested for safety and nutrition. We’re proud of our spotless recall record
At what age should I spay or neuter my dog or cat?
Most veterinarians recommend spaying or neutering pets around 6 months of age, but the ideal timing can vary depending on breed, size, and health. Always consult your vet to determine the best age for your pet.
Can I get free samples of cat food before committing?
Yes! We’re happy to deliver free cat food samples straight to your door, so you can see what your cat loves before committing to a bigger bag.
Can I get recommendations while shopping if I’m not sure what to buy?
Of course! If you’re unsure, our team provides personalized shopping guidance—helping you choose the right food for allergies, sensitivities, weight management, puppies, seniors, and more.
Can I set up a recurring delivery for my cat’s food?
Yes. Our flexible subscription service lets you schedule regular deliveries of your cat’s favorite food. You’ll never run out, and subscriptions can be paused, changed, or canceled anytime.
Do Holistic Choice recipes support long-term health better than mainstream foods?
Yes! Our small-batch, slow-cooked recipes lock in vital nutrients that support immune health, digestion, joint care, and long-term vitality. Unlike many mainstream foods that cut corners for cost efficiency, Holistic Choice ensures your pet gets the full benefits of real, nutrient-rich nutrition.
Do you carry grain-free and sensitive stomach cat food?
Yes! We offer both grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes, along with special options for cats with sensitive stomachs, food allergies, or digestive issues. Our team is always here to help you find the formula that best fits your cat’s unique needs.
Do you offer healthy treats for cats?
Yes! The Pet Pantry carries a selection of nutritious, cat-approved treats made without fillers or harmful additives—perfect for rewarding your cat while supporting their overall health.
Do you sell only Holistic Choice cat food?
No. While we specialize in our exclusive Holistic Choice brand, we also carry a variety of high-quality national brands for cat food, treats, and supplies—giving you plenty of options to shop from.
Does The Pet Pantry offer a guarantee for the Holistic Choice food?
We stand by our 100% satisfaction guarantee—if you’re not happy, we’ll make it right or refund your purchase. No hassles, no small print.
How do I know which recipe is best for my pet?
Each of our recipes is formulated by small-animal nutritionists and veterinarians to support different life stages, breed sizes, and health needs. If you’re unsure which recipe is right, just reach out to us. Our team loves helping pet parents find the paw-fect match for their furry family members
How is Holistic Choice pet food made?
Holistic Choice is made with care from start to finish. We start by selecting human-quality proteins, wholesome grains, and farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, all sourced in the USA. Each recipe is then slow-cooked in small batches at lower temperatures to preserve nutrients, flavor, and digestibility. Finally, every batch is tested for safety and quality before it ever reaches your pet’s bowl. This makes a nutrient-dense food that supports better digestion, a stronger immune system, shiny coats, and long-term vitality.
The Pet Pantry vs Chewy and Amazon: Why buy local instead?
Chewy and Amazon carry lots of options, but they don’t focus on personalized nutrition. Holistic Choice comes straight from The Pet Pantry, your local NC company known for award-winning service and free same-day delivery in the Triangle. Unlike the big anonymous retailers, we offer custom food recommendations and a 100% satisfaction guarantee—because your pet deserves more than just a box at the door.
What health benefits can I expect from feeding Holistic Choice?
Pet parents report shinier coats, healthier skin, stronger immune systems, better digestion, improved stool quality, and more consistent energy after switching to Holistic Choice.
What makes Holistic Choice cat food different?
Made with the same care you’d want for your own family. Each recipe is crafted with human-grade proteins, wholesome grains, and natural vitamins, then slow-cooked in small batches to lock in nutrients and flavor. You’ll never find by-products, corn, wheat, soy, GMOs, or artificial preservatives—just clean, highly digestible nutrition that supports healthy skin, shiny coats, strong teeth, and balanced energy.
What types of cat food does The Pet Pantry offer?
We carry a full range of dry food, wet food, and specialty formulas for cats—including our super-premium Holistic Choice recipes alongside trusted national brands. Whether you have a playful kitten, an active adult, or a wise senior, you’ll find the perfect nutrition to keep them happy and healthy.
Do I have to sign up for a subscription?
Not at all! You can order as needed or set up an optional subscription for automatic deliveries—whatever works best for you. Unlike the big-box companies, we keep pricing the same whether you subscribe or not.
What’s the difference between a subscription order and an auto order? Which should I choose?

Subscription (Online Self-Service)

  • You set it up and manage it yourself in your online account.
  • Best for standard, repeatable orders (e.g., 40 lbs of the same food every month).
  • Easy to update anytime — change items, quantities, or delivery frequency on your own.
  • Ideal if you want full control and the flexibility to make quick adjustments.

Auto Order (Manually Managed by Our Office)

  • We set it up for you and manage it in our in-office system.
  • Works for orders that can’t be placed online, such as:
    • Sample bags instead of full-sized bags
    • Special blends or custom combinations of multiple foods
  • Requires storing a payment method with our office staff instead of online.

If you’re unsure which option fits your situation best, just reach out — we’re happy to recommend the right setup for your needs.

How do I set up a subscription?

Setting up a subscription is quick and easy:

  • Go to the product page for any food, treat, or supply you want to receive regularly.
  • Choose your quantity.
  • Click “Subscribe” (located under the Quantity selector).
  • Select your delivery frequency from the dropdown.
    (Not sure how often to order? Use the built-in calculator next to the dropdown.)
  • Click “Add to Cart.”
  • Repeat for any other items you’d like to include in your subscription.
  • Checkout as normal. Once your order is placed, your subscription becomes active.
  • Your first subscription order will be delivered on your area’s next delivery day.
    (Want to postpone the first delivery? Just let us know!)

What are the benefits of setting up a subscription?

Setting up a subscription makes feeding your pets easier and more consistent:

  • Never run out of food or treats — orders renew automatically on your schedule.
  • Keep feeding amounts consistent, especially helpful in multi-person households.
  • Easy to update anytime — change items, quantities, or timing whenever you need.
  • Take advantage of monthly specials by adding sale items or coupon codes to your next subscription order.
  • Adjust as life changes — add more food, treats, or items anytime if your household grows.

Subscriptions keep things simple, predictable, and totally flexible.

Are there any discounts if I set up a subscription?

We don’t believe in pressuring our customers into a subscription by offering “subscription discounts.” Your everyday price is already our best price.

However, we do offer a bulk per-pound discount on all Holistic Choice foods:

  • The more you order at once, the lower your cost per pound.
  • For example, 60 lbs in one order costs less per pound than 20 lbs in one order.

Subscriptions themselves aren’t discounted — but ordering in larger quantities always saves you money.

How do I calculate how often I should receive my subscription?

Our built-in calculator makes it easy:

  • Go to the food you want to subscribe to and choose your bag size/quantity.
  • Click Subscribe.
  • Next to the frequency dropdown, select Calculate Food Subscription.
  • Enter:
    • How many 8 oz. cups you feed per day
    • How many pounds are in the bag you’re ordering
  • The calculator will automatically recommend the best delivery schedule.

Example: If you feed 2 cups per day and order a 40-lb bag, the calculator may suggest a delivery every 3 months.

How do I change the type of food in my subscription?

You can update your food blend or quantity anytime:

  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • Click View on the subscription you want to update.
  • Click the X next to the food you want to remove, then Save.
  • Find the new food on our website and open the product page.
  • Choose your quantity and click Subscribe.
  • Select Add to an Existing Subscription and choose the subscription you’re updating.
  • Your delivery schedule will stay the same unless you update it in your Subscriptions page.
How do I know when my subscription will renew?
  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • You’ll see all your active subscriptions listed with a Next Payment date — this is your renewal date.
  • When your subscription renews, your order will be delivered either:
    • The same day, if it renews before your area’s delivery cutoff, or
    • On your next delivery day, if it renews after cutoff.
  • Example: If you live in Apex and your subscription renews Monday afternoon, your order will arrive on Tuesday.
How do I reactivate a subscription that’s on hold?

Reactivating is simple:

  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • Under your inactive subscriptions, click Reactivate.
  • Make sure your saved payment method is current—your order will process immediately and deliver on your area’s next delivery day.
  • If you reactivate but don’t need the order right away, just email us at info@feedyourpets.com or call 919-303-1990 and we’ll adjust the delivery date for you.

How do I remove an item from my subscription?

You can remove items anytime:

  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • Find the subscription you want to update and click View.
  • Click the X next to any item you want to remove.
  • Select OK to confirm.
    Your subscription total will update automatically.

Can I add items to my existing subscription?

Yes! Here’s how:

  • Find the item you want on our website and open the product page.
  • Make sure it shows “Available on Subscription.”
  • Click Subscribe (under the “Purchase One Time” button).
  • Choose Add to an Existing Subscription when the option appears.
  • Select which subscription you’d like the item added to.

Can I change the frequency of my subscription?

Yes! It’s easy to update your subscription schedule:

  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • Find the subscription you want to update and click View.
  • Look for Subscription Frequency and click Change Frequency.
  • Select your new delivery frequency from the dropdown.
  • Click Save to apply your changes.

Can I have multiple subscriptions with different schedules?

Yes! You can set up as many separate subscriptions as you need.

Here’s how:

  • For each item you want on its own schedule, go to the product page and click Subscribe.
  • Choose the delivery frequency you want.
  • Do not select Add to an Existing Subscription—that would combine it with another schedule.
  • Add the item(s) to your cart and checkout normally.
    Your new subscription will start its own delivery cycle.

You can create separate subscriptions for dog food, cat food, treats, litter—whatever works best for your home.

Can I put my subscription on hold?

Yes! You can pause your subscription anytime:

  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • Click View next to the subscription you want to pause.
  • Select Suspend.
  • Your subscription will remain on hold until you choose to reactivate it.

How can I see the frequency of my subscription?
  • Go to My AccountSubscriptions.
  • You’ll see all active and inactive subscriptions listed.
  • Under the Total column, you’ll find your subscription amount and its delivery frequency.
The Pet Pantry Subscription Service vs Subscription Pet Food Services: Which offers more flexibility?
Many subscription services trap customers with rigid schedules, hidden fees, or higher prices if you don’t subscribe. At The Pet Pantry, we value our customers too much to do that. You’re always in control—order whenever you like, set up a no-commitment subscription, or even try free samples first. And with our own local delivery fleet, your pet’s food arrives fresh, fast, and without shipping delays.
The Pet Pantry vs Chewy and Amazon: Why buy local instead?
Chewy and Amazon carry lots of options, but they don’t focus on personalized nutrition. Holistic Choice comes straight from The Pet Pantry, your local NC company known for award-winning service and free same-day delivery in the Triangle. Unlike the big anonymous retailers, we offer custom food recommendations and a 100% satisfaction guarantee—because your pet deserves more than just a box at the door.
How does the free delivery work?
It’s simple! Place your order online, email or by phone, and we’ll deliver it straight to your door—fast and free, if you are located in the delivery zone. No hidden fees, no tipping, no subscription required. For more information, please visit our delivery zones page to discover in which zone you are.
Are there extra fees for delivery or tipping drivers?
Nope—never! At The Pet Pantry, delivery is always free within our service zone, and we don’t believe in hidden fees. Our drivers are part of our team, not third-party contractors, so tipping is not expected. The best “tip” you can give is a smile (or a happy tail wag from your pet)!
Can I shop for both dog and cat food on the same order?
Yes! Our online shop allows you to add products from multiple categories—dog, cat, or other animals—into a single order. We make it easy to feed all your pets with one convenient checkout.
Can I shop for food for multiple types of pets in one order?
Absolutely. You can add products for dogs, cats, and other animals all in the same shopping cart, making it easy to care for your whole pet family in one convenient delivery.
Can I shop for specialty dog food, like weight control or sensitive stomach formulas?
Absolutely. Our selection includes weight management recipes, skin & coat support, and allergy-friendly options, including both Holistic Choice and other carefully selected brands.
Are The Pet Pantry’s foods safe and tested?
Yes! Every batch is slow-cooked in small quantities to preserve nutrients and is rigorously tested for safety and nutrition. We’re proud of our spotless recall record
Can I get free samples of cat food before committing?
Yes! We’re happy to deliver free cat food samples straight to your door, so you can see what your cat loves before committing to a bigger bag.
Can I schedule recurring deliveries so I never run out of pet food?
Yes! Our optional subscription service ensures you never run out. You choose the frequency, and we deliver automatically—always with the option to pause or adjust at any time.
Do I have to sign up for a subscription?
Not at all! You can order as needed or set up an optional subscription for automatic deliveries—whatever works best for you. Unlike the big-box companies, we keep pricing the same whether you subscribe or not.
Do you deliver to apartments or gated communities?
Yes, we deliver to houses, apartments, and gated communities. Just provide delivery instructions (such as gate codes or preferred drop-off spots) at checkout to ensure smooth delivery.
Does The Pet Pantry deliver outside of North Carolina?
Yes. While local deliveries are free, we also offer flat-rate shipping to parts of North Carolina and use affordable shipping options to deliver nationwide. Delivery fees vary depending on location and carrier rates
Does The Pet Pantry offer a guarantee for the Holistic Choice food?
We stand by our 100% satisfaction guarantee—if you’re not happy, we’ll make it right or refund your purchase. No hassles, no small print.
Does The Pet Pantry offer free delivery?
Yes! We provide free home delivery in the greater Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill area (Triangle) and Greensboro, Winston-Salem, Lexington, Asheboro area (Triad), with flat-rate shipping in parts of North Carolina and affordable nationwide delivery by UPS. To discover if you are in the free shipping area, please visit our delivery zones page.
How are the free samples delivered?
Free samples are delivered straight to your doorstep. If you’re in the Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill Triangle, samples are delivered locally at no cost. For customers outside our local zones, we ship using affordable delivery options.
How is my pet’s food kept fresh during delivery?
We carefully handle all orders to maintain freshness and quality from our warehouse to your doorstep. All deliveries in our Free Delivery Zone are made with our own fleet of trucks and employees, not third party contractors. For longer shipping routes outside NC, we use secure packaging designed to preserve product quality.
If I don’t live in your Free Delivery Zone can I have my orders delivered to me at work or to a family/friends home?
Absolutely! If you’re outside our Free Delivery Zone, you can still enjoy the convenience of The Pet Pantry by having your order delivered to a workplace, family member, or friend’s home within our delivery area. Many pet parents use this option to make sure their pets never miss a meal. We’ll work with you to find the delivery spot that’s most convenient!
Is The Pet Pantry locally owned?
Yes, we’ve been locally owned and operated in North Carolina for nearly 20 years, and we’re proud to support our community with personalized service
The Pet Pantry vs Chewy and Amazon: Why buy local instead?
Chewy and Amazon carry lots of options, but they don’t focus on personalized nutrition. Holistic Choice comes straight from The Pet Pantry, your local NC company known for award-winning service and free same-day delivery in the Triangle. Unlike the big anonymous retailers, we offer custom food recommendations and a 100% satisfaction guarantee—because your pet deserves more than just a box at the door.
What if my pet doesn’t like the food?
We stand behind every recipe. If for any reason you or your pet aren’t completely happy, we’ll refund your purchase. No hassles, no worries—just our promise to keep you and your pet satisfied.
What time do I need to place my order to qualify for same-day delivery?
Place your order by 9:00 a.m. for free same-day local delivery in our Triangle service area. Orders after 9:00 a.m. are typically delivered the next delivery day.
Where does The Pet Pantry deliver?
Yes! We provide free home delivery in the greater Raleigh-Durham-Chapel Hill area (Triangle) and Greensboro, Winston-Salem, Lexington, Asheboro area (Triad), with flat-rate shipping in parts of North Carolina and affordable nationwide delivery by UPS.
Why does my dog roll in smelly things?

Ah, the age-old question: why do our adorable, tail-wagging companions insist on rolling in things that smell, quite frankly, like they crawled out of a dumpster's darkest nightmares?

The answer lies in your dog’s inner wolf! Rolling in smelly stuff is an ancient, instinctual behavior inherited from their wild ancestors. Back in the day, wolves used this trick to mask their scent with the eau de stinky surprise. Why? To either confuse prey (like, "I smell like rotten fish now, not a hungry wolf!") or communicate something interesting to the pack, like, "Check out this amazing smell I found!" It’s basically the canine version of sharing a meme—except smellier.

So next time your pup dives headfirst into the smelliest thing around, remember: it’s not mischief, it’s primal artistry. Just maybe keep the garden hose handy for the after-party!

Why does my dog do the “Booty Scoot Boogie”?

Picture this: your dog, usually the picture of grace (or at least close enough), suddenly drops their butt to the ground and takes off like they’re starring in a weird version of Fast & Furious: Rug Burn Edition. This charming little move, known as “scooting,” is usually their way of dealing with a very specific problem—anal gland irritation.

Anal glands are two tiny sacs near their rear end that nature, in its infinite wisdom, decided every dog needed. When functioning properly, these glands release a smelly substance that helps dogs mark their territory. (Yes, it’s as gross as it sounds.) But when they get clogged or impacted, it’s like having an itch they just can’t scratch. Cue the scooting!

Dragging their rear across the ground is your dog’s attempt to relieve the irritation. To them, it’s a practical solution. To you, it’s a mix of horror (goodbye clean floors!) and concern (time to call the vet).

So next time you catch your dog doing their best impersonation of a furry mop, give them some empathy—and maybe a vet appointment. After all, no one likes a clogged-up rear, and your dog is just trying to make the best of a very awkward situation!

Why does my dog move their food out of their bowl before eating?

Ah, the classic "doggy dinner dash!" Your pup might be moving their food out of the bowl because they're embracing their inner food critic or staging a one-dog dinner party. Here are some possibilities for this quirky behavior:

Primal Instincts: Long ago, their wild ancestors would drag food to a "safer" spot to chow down without interruptions. Your dog might just be channeling their inner wolf while living their best domesticated life.

Bowl Blues: Maybe the bowl is too small, too noisy, or just not their vibe. Some bowls can clang or reflect light in weird ways that your dog finds annoying.

Texture Preference: Dogs can be picky about surfaces—perhaps your pup prefers the floor over a bowl because it feels more natural or comfortable to eat from.

Why does my dog search for a place to poop?

Dogs are basically the divas of the animal kingdom when it comes to picking the perfect potty spot. They’ll circle, sniff, and ponder like they're deciding on the best seat in the house. Maybe they’re marking their turf, checking out the local smells, scouting for a soft patch of grass, or maybe they’re aligning their chi with the Earth's magnetic field. Who knows? It’s all part of their highly sophisticated, sensory-driven bathroom routine.

Why does my dog sleep in such weird positions?

Your dog contorts into positions that would make a yoga instructor wince: pretzel twists, belly-up with all four legs pointed to the heavens, or draped halfway off the couch like they’re auditioning for a canine soap opera called As the Nap Turns. You can’t tell if they’re napping or performing some avant-garde art installation.

Why: Dogs don’t have the same societal pressures we do—they’re blissfully free from the need to sleep in “normal” positions. These quirky poses often mean they’re super comfortable, trying to cool off, or just so utterly exhausted that they couldn’t care less if they look like a furry pretzel.

Of course, it also doubles as pure comedy gold. These goofy sleep shapes are tailor-made for Instagram. Snap a pic, add a witty caption, and don’t forget to tag us @thepetpantry so we can laugh along with you. Bonus points if your dog somehow manages to combine “upside-down starfish” with “hanging-off-the-couch noodle.” Nap on, little weirdo, nap on.

Why does my dog try to smother me?

Why does your dog smother you? Oh, friend, you’ve unlocked the ultimate doggo love language: extreme closeness. If your pup is anything like ours, you’ve probably found yourself thinking, “Am I a human or a canine couch?” Whether they’re perched on your feet, sprawled across your lap like a furry throw blanket, or turning bedtime into a cozy (and slightly claustrophobic) cuddle fest, they’re sending a clear message: You are my favorite thing in the whole world, and I must physically merge with you.

But don’t worry—this isn’t some weird dominance thing. No, no, no. They’re just showing you how much they adore you. Dogs are pack animals, and their inner wolf says, “Stick close to the pack for safety, warmth, and belly rubs.” Guess what? To them, you are the pack! Their snuggle-fest instincts are telling them, “Hey, life is better when we’re squished together.”

So next time your pooch plops onto you mid-movie or transforms into a 40-pound heating pad at 2 a.m., just remember: it’s not smothering—it’s love.

Why does my dog hump my leg, stuffed animal, pillow, etc.?

Watching your dog go to town on a stuffed toy can be one of those “look away but can’t stop peeking” moments. Rest assured, it’s perfectly normal! Dogs hump for all kinds of reasons—sometimes it feels good, sometimes it helps them blow off steam, and other times it’s their way of channeling an overload of excitement. Both male and female dogs do it, though the fellas tend to lead the pack in this department.

If your dog starts humping a fellow pet, a human leg, or the couch cushions, take a deep breath—it’s not always about dominance, and it’s not usually sexual either. In fact, humping is often just a part of canine play or even an outlet for pent-up energy. Poor socialization or too much excitement can also lead to this behavior, but don’t sweat it—it’s not a reflection on your parenting!

When dogs hump objects, like their favorite stuffed giraffe, it’s often because… well, it just feels good. If it starts happening more often than you’re comfortable with, though, it’s a good idea to check in with your vet to make sure everything’s A-OK.

And here’s the kicker: sometimes, dogs keep humping simply because it gets your attention. Laugh, react, or even just give them attention, and your pup might think they’ve hit the jackpot! So, if you’re looking to dial down the hump-a-thon, keep your cool and redirect their energy with a toy or a quick game instead.

Why does my dog eat grass?

Behavior: Your furry carnivore suddenly thinks they’re a cow, munching on grass like it’s the salad bar special.

Why: Theories abound! No one really knows why dogs munch on grass—maybe they're just into leafy snacks? Scientists think it might just taste good to them, like a salad bar for canines. The old idea that dogs eat grass to make themselves throw up? Total myth, since most pups don’t actually hurl afterward. Generally, it’s no big deal unless your furry friend goes overboard and starts treating your lawn like an all-you-can-eat buffet—then you might have a problem with a clogged puppy pipeline!

Why does my dog eat poop?

There are countless theories about why dogs decide to snack on poop, and honestly, it seems like each pup might have their own… unique reason for this gross-yet-strangely-common behavior.

Could it be that some dogs genuinely enjoy the taste of poop?
Disgusting? Yes.
Normal? Also yes. (Dogs, what even are you?)

Is it a learned behavior?
One popular theory (and a personal favorite) suggests that some dogs pick up this delightful habit by watching their moms clean up after them as puppies. Or maybe they saw their canine BFF munching away and thought, "Wow, that looks like a great idea—can’t miss out on the fun!" Peer pressure strikes again.

Or is it evolutionary?
Dogs evolved as scavengers, so eating poop might have been a survival hack back in the day. Nutrient-dense and low on the competition? Bon appétit! (Kind of.)

Honorable Mentions:
Stress, anxiety, or boredom: A stressed-out or bored dog might think, "You know what could spice up this lonely day? Poop."
Punishment trauma: If your dog got scolded for accidents in the house, they might think eating poop is the ultimate cover-up.
Medical reasons: Conditions like Cushing’s disease, thyroid issues, malabsorption, or worms could all play a role. If poop is on the menu, a vet check is always a good idea.

How do I get my dog to stop eating poop?

How to Help Your Dog Kick the Poop-Eating Habit (Because Eww):

Digestive Enzymes: Sprinkle these miracle helpers into their food to make sure they’re getting all the nutrients they need. Sometimes dogs go for “seconds” because their body missed the first serving. It’s like nutritional FOMO—but way grosser.

Pineapple Magic: Believe it or not, a little pineapple in their diet can work wonders. It changes the taste of their poop from “hmm, maybe” to “absolutely not.” Even by dog standards, this turns their “snack” into a hard pass. Pineapple: the poop-deterrent MVP.

The Speedy Cleanup Method: Think of it as a race. You vs. your dog. The goal? Remove the offending poop before your pup decides to treat it like an all-you-can-eat buffet. Bonus: Your yard stays cleaner, and your dog’s breath stays… well, less horrifying.

Let’s face it, dogs are amazing, lovable, and endlessly entertaining. But sometimes? They’re just so weird. We love you, puppers, but please—let’s keep the snacks strictly out of the poop category, okay?

Why does my dog chase their tail?

Most of the time, it’s just playtime fun or a way to burn off energy. Some pups do it for attention, others just love the spin! But if it’s constant or looks uncomfortable, it could be irritation or something worth a vet check. When in doubt, trust your instincts

Why does my dog carry my sock around?

Behavior: Socks, shoes, and literally anything you kind of need instantly transform into your dog’s most prized possessions. Your favorite sock? Oh, that’s now a trophy. Your shoe? A chewable masterpiece. Your TV remote? Well, good luck changing the channel because it’s officially a “dog treasure” now.

Why: To them, these items are like little pieces of you that they can carry around. Your scent is basically their favorite perfume, and clutching your sock like it’s the crown jewels is their way of feeling close to you—even if it leaves your footwear permanently soggy.

Of course, they could also just be showing off. Dogs are basically furry little kleptomaniacs with a flair for drama. One person’s laundry pile is another dog’s treasure chest! So next time you find yourself searching for your left shoe or mysteriously mismatched socks, just remember: in your dog’s eyes, this is their version of showing love. Slobbery, slightly inconvenient love.

Why does my dog dig holes all over the backyard?

Your once-lovely backyard now resembles a lunar landscape, complete with craters big enough to make NASA jealous. Meanwhile, your dog surveys the destruction with a proud “Look what I made!” expression, like they’re auditioning for an HGTV show called Backyard Chaos: Canine Edition.

Why: Dogs dig for all kinds of reasons. Maybe they’re bored and decided your yard needed some “improvements.” Or they’re trying to cool off and thought, “Why not turn this patch of dirt into a luxury dog spa?” And let’s not forget their natural instinct to bury “treasures.” Your missing garden glove? Yeah, it’s probably stashed in their underground vault.

Essentially, your dog is a wannabe archaeologist—minus the degree, funding, and any sense of preservation. To them, every dig is a groundbreaking adventure of discovery. Sure, you might see a mess, but your dog sees the beginnings of their very own historical dig. Who knows? Maybe they’ll uncover something ancient. Or maybe just the bone they buried yesterday.

Why does my dog do Zoomies?

Oh, absolutely! Zoomies—technically known as Frenetic Random Activity Periods (FRAPs)—are a totally natural dog behavior. Basically, it’s your dog’s way of turning into a furry, four-legged tornado of joy. Most of the time, it’s nothing to worry about. In fact, instead of just watching in awe (or mild terror), consider joining in! Trust me, there’s no better way to bond with your pup than matching their energy with your own awkward human zoomies.

Why Do Dogs Zoom?
Great question. The reasons behind zoomies are as varied as the goofy moves your dog pulls off mid-sprint:

Releasing Energy: Sometimes, your dog has so much pent-up energy they just have to let it out. It’s like someone flipped a switch, and suddenly your living room becomes a racetrack.
Alleviating Stress: Had a rough day barking at the mail carrier? Nothing a good case of zoomies can’t fix!
Under-Stimulation: Let’s face it, dogs get bored too. Zoomies are the canine equivalent of scrolling through memes—an instant boredom buster.
Excitement Overload: Did you just grab the leash? Are there new people or animals in the mix? Or maybe you opened a bag of treats? If so, congratulations—you’ve triggered a Zoomie Event. Expect laps, spins, and possibly some furniture casualties.
Pro Tip: Next time your dog takes off at warp speed, don’t just stand there. Laugh, cheer them on, or even try your own awkward zoomie version. Who cares if your neighbors think you’ve lost it? Dogs zoom because life is exciting—and we could all use a little more zoomie energy in our lives!

Why does my dog turn in circles and dig at their bed before lying down?

The circling? That’s their ancient doggy brain whispering, "Better fluff this grass or dirt to make it perfect." Never mind that it’s already softer than your own bed—they’re convinced they need to put their pawsonal touch on it.

The digging? Oh, that’s just their inner wild dog saying, "Let me find the cool dirt under here!" even though all they’re doing is pawing at your expensive duvet. And don’t forget the scent marking—those little scrapes release the secret eau de paw that says, "Mine, mine, mine!" If that weren’t enough, the circling also doubles as their version of a predator check. You know, just in case a saber-toothed tiger is lurking under the couch in your suburban living room.

In reality, though, it’s mostly ritual. Dogs don’t need to do this anymore, but they still can’t resist the bedtime dance passed down from their wild ancestors. It’s part archaeology, part security sweep, and 100% drama queen behavior. Just let them spin, dig, and flop—they’re making sure their sleep is worthy of royalty.

Why is it important to spay or neuter my pet?
Spaying and neutering help prevent unwanted litters, reduce pet overpopulation, and lower the risk of certain health problems such as uterine infections, breast cancer, and testicular cancer. It also supports better behavior and a longer, healthier life for your pet.

Happy
Woof Day!

Let's celebrate your furry friend's Birthday or Gotcha day together!

Thanks for joining The Pet Pantry Birthday Club — we can’t wait to celebrate special days with you! 🐾

Your Information*

This field is required.
This field is required.

Your Pets' Information*

This field is required.
This field is required.
Choose Gift*
  • Toy
  • Treat
This field is required.

By joining the b-day club you agree to receive email communications from The Pet Pantry. The Birthday Club is for active Pet Pantry customers only.