Choosing the right food for your furry friend can feel overwhelming.
Compare Your Brand
Focus on what really matters.
- Ingredients – Look for a quality protein source as the first ingredient. Avoid foods with by-products or fillers
- Steer clear of corn, wheat, soy, GMO’s, chemical preservatives, or artificial anything
- Added benefits – Probiotics, omegas, glucosamine & chondroitin, antioxidants
- Cooking process – Foods gently cooked at low temperatures preserve nutrients better than high-heat methods
- Transparency and safety – Strict quality standards and no recalls
Look beyond flashy packaging & advertising when comparing foods. You deserve to know what’s in your pet’s bowl.
Brand Comparison
| Brand | The Pet Pantry Holistic Choice |
Purina ProPlan | PurinaOne | Hill’s | Blue Buffalo | Iams |
| Food Blend | Holistic Chicken & Brown Rice 2 x 20 lb. bags | Pro Plan Complete Essentials Chicken & Rice Formula w/ Probiotics- 35 lb. | Adult Chicken & Rice Formula – 40 lb. bag | Hill’s Science Diet Adult Chicken & Barley Dog Food – 35 lb. | Life Protection Formula – Chicken & Brown Rice – 30 lb. | Proactive Health Minichunks Chicken & Whole Grains – 30 lb. |
| Price Per lb.* | $ 2.07 | $2.18 | $1.53 | $2.32 | $2.30 | $1.44 |
| Protein Sources | Chicken, Whitefish | Chicken, Wheat, Corn, Soybean | Chicken, Corn, Wheat, Soybean | Chicken, Wheat, Corn, Soybean | Chicken | Chicken, Corn |
| By-products | NO | Yes | Yes | No | No | Yes |
| Corn, Wheat or Soy | NO | Wheat, Corn, Soybean | Corn, Wheat, Soybean | Wheat, Corn, Soybean | No | Corn |
| All Ingredients sourced in USA | YES | No | No | No | No | No |
| Human Quality Ingredients | YES | No | No | No | No | No |
| Probiotics | YES | Yes | No | Yes | No | No |
| Glucosamine & Chondroitin | YES | Glucosamine only | No | No | Glucosamine only | No |
| Slow-cooked at low temperatures | YES | No | No | No | No | No |
*Prices calculated from chewy.com 10/2/2025
Only the good stuff!
Holistic Choice Recipes
- First ingredient is animal protein source
- Human-quality ingredients – No by-products, chemicals, fillers, corn, wheat or soy
- Antioxidants, probiotics, joint support, omegas, and much more
- Slow-cooked at low temps in small batches
- Spotless safety record, zero recalls
- 5-star customer service
Our customers' comparison
Thousands of reviews available on Google, Facebook, Nextdoor and Yelp!
F.A.Q.'s
Can I shop for specialty dog food, like weight control or sensitive stomach formulas?
Absolutely. Our selection includes weight management recipes, skin & coat support, and allergy-friendly options, including both Holistic Choice and other carefully selected brands.
Can The Pet Pantry help me choose the right food for my pet?
Absolutely. Whether your pet has allergies, weight issues, or is a picky eater, our team provides personalized recommendations to make sure every meal supports your pet’s health.
Do grain-free diets cause Dilated Cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs?
In 2018, the FDA began investigating reports of DCM in dogs eating certain grain-free foods, particularly those high in legumes like peas, lentils, or chickpeas. No evidence has been found linking grain-free foods and DCM in dogs.
Do Holistic Choice recipes support long-term health better than mainstream foods?
Yes! Our small-batch, slow-cooked recipes lock in vital nutrients that support immune health, digestion, joint care, and long-term vitality. Unlike many mainstream foods that cut corners for cost efficiency, Holistic Choice ensures your pet gets the full benefits of real, nutrient-rich nutrition.
Do you offer grain-free and grain-inclusive options in your shop?
Absolutely. Whether your pet thrives on a grain-free diet or prefers wholesome grains like brown rice, our Holistic Choice recipes and partner brands cover both options, making it simple to shop based on your pet’s needs.
Do you only sell The Pet Pantry’s Holistic Choice, or other brands too?
While we specialize in our Holistic Choice brand, you can also shop from a selection of trusted national brands for food, treats, and toys, giving you the best mix of premium, health-focused options.
Does Holistic Choice have a better recall record than national brands?
Yes! Holistic Choice has a spotless recall record—something we’re very proud of. Every batch is carefully tested before it reaches your door to guarantee safety and nutrition. Unlike big brands like Purina or Iams, which have faced multiple recalls, Holistic Choice gives you peace of mind and consistent, reliable quality in every bowl.
Does The Pet Pantry deliver outside of North Carolina?
Yes. While local deliveries are free, we also offer flat-rate shipping to parts of North Carolina and use affordable shipping options to deliver nationwide. Delivery fees vary depending on location and carrier rates
Holistic Choice vs Farmer’s Dog: Which is more convenient and cost-effective?
Farmer’s Dog offers fresh-frozen meals, but they require freezer space, thawing time, and come with a hefty price tag. Holistic Choice delivers the same premium nutrition in a shelf-stable kibble that’s simple to store, scoop, and serve—without the mess or extra cost. For many pet parents, it’s the smarter balance of top-quality nutrition and everyday convenience.
Holistic Choice vs Fresh Pet: What’s the nutritional advantage?
Fresh Pet promotes itself as a fresh option, but with its high moisture content and need for refrigeration, it comes with a shorter shelf life and a higher cost per meal. Holistic Choice kibble is nutrient-dense, highly digestible, and shelf-stable, giving your pet the benefits of fresh, wholesome ingredients—without the hassle.
Holistic Choice vs Grocery Store Brands: Is it worth paying more?
Yes! Grocery store brands like Purina Dog Chow or Iams often rely on fillers, by-products, and artificial preservatives to cut costs. Holistic Choice leaves out the cheap stuff and packs in premium nutrition with every bite. That means you feed less, see better results, and often save on vet bills in the long run.
Holistic Choice vs Iams: Which is healthier for my pet?
Holistic Choice is slow-cooked in small batches with clean, USA-sourced ingredients to preserve nutrients and maximize health benefits. While Iams may be convenient and affordable, it often relies on by-products, fillers, and artificial additives. With Holistic Choice, you’re giving your pet a nutrient-dense diet focused on long-term health—not just short-term convenience.
Holistic Choice vs Purina: What’s the difference?
Holistic Choice is made with human-quality proteins, whole grains, and natural vitamins—never by-products, fillers, or artificial preservatives. By contrast, brands like Purina often rely on meat by-products, corn, wheat, and soy as main ingredients. Pet parents who make the switch to Holistic Choice typically notice better digestion, shinier coats, and fewer allergy concerns in their pets.
How do I know which recipe is best for my pet?
Each of our recipes is formulated by small-animal nutritionists and veterinarians to support different life stages, breed sizes, and health needs. If you’re unsure which recipe is right, just reach out to us. Our team loves helping pet parents find the paw-fect match for their furry family members
What health benefits can I expect from feeding Holistic Choice?
Pet parents report shinier coats, healthier skin, stronger immune systems, better digestion, improved stool quality, and more consistent energy after switching to Holistic Choice.
What ingredients are used in Holistic Choice recipes?
Holistic Choice recipes are made with the kind of ingredients you can feel good about: real, human-quality proteins, wholesome whole grains, nutritious fruits and vegetables, natural vitamins and minerals to support balanced, complete nutrition. You’ll never find by-products, fillers, corn, wheat, soy, GMOs, or artificial preservatives in our foods. Just clean, USA-sourced goodness crafted in small batches to help your pet thrive with better digestion, shinier coats, and more energy.
What makes slow-cooking at lower temperatures better?
Slow-cooking at lower temperatures helps preserve the natural nutrients, flavors, and integrity of each ingredient. Unlike high-heat methods that can break down proteins and vitamins, our gentle process locks in nutrition so your pet gets the full benefits of wholesome, real-food ingredients. It also enhances digestibility and taste, making every meal both healthier and more enjoyable for your pet.
What makes Holistic Choice different from other pet foods?
Holistic Choice is our own exclusive brand, handcrafted in small batches and slow-cooked at low temperatures right here in the USA. We use only human-grade ingredients with no by-products, fillers, GMOs, or artificial additives—just real, wholesome nutrition you can feel good about. Pets thrive on our recipes, and their humans love the noticeable difference in energy, digestion, skin, coat and overall vitality
What makes The Pet Pantry different from other pet food companies?
We specialize in premium nutrition with our exclusive Holistic Choice brand and a curated selection of trusted partner products. Plus, our local delivery, personalized service, and 100% satisfaction guarantee set us apart from national chains
Happy
Woof Day!
Let's celebrate your furry friend's Birthday or Gotcha day together!
Thanks for joining The Pet Pantry Birthday Club — we can’t wait to celebrate special days with you! 🐾
Pet’s name
Birthday
20.05.2020
Dog/Cat
B-Day Gift
This field is required.
This field is required.
Choose Gift*
- Toy
- Treat
Your Pets' Information*
This field is required.
This field is required.
Choose Gift*
- Toy
- Treat