For Your Pet – Crafted by Experts
Our recipes are created by veterinarians, scientists, and nutritionists to go beyond basic nutrition. Every bowl is designed to help your pet live a happier, healthier, and longer life.
All Natural – Our Holistic Philosophy
Every ingredient is chosen with purpose—to nourish your pet and support their health. We source exclusively from trusted U.S. farmers and never use fillers or over processed ingredients. The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.
Safety First – Tested at Every Step
From start to finish, we test every ingredient and every batch—before cooking, during the process, and after it’s done. Our strict safety standards and reliable supplier partnerships have kept us recall-free for over 20 years.
You can search for specific ingredients commonly found in pet foods using the alphabetical list below
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
K
L
M
N
O
P
R
S
T
V
W
Y
Z
F.A.Q.'s
Can The Pet Pantry help me choose the right food for my pet?
Absolutely. Whether your pet has allergies, weight issues, or is a picky eater, our team provides personalized recommendations to make sure every meal supports your pet’s health.
Do Holistic Choice recipes support long-term health better than mainstream foods?
Yes! Our small-batch, slow-cooked recipes lock in vital nutrients that support immune health, digestion, joint care, and long-term vitality. Unlike many mainstream foods that cut corners for cost efficiency, Holistic Choice ensures your pet gets the full benefits of real, nutrient-rich nutrition.
Do you carry grain-free and sensitive stomach cat food?
Yes! We offer both grain-free and grain-inclusive recipes, along with special options for cats with sensitive stomachs, food allergies, or digestive issues. Our team is always here to help you find the formula that best fits your cat’s unique needs.
Do you offer grain-free and grain-inclusive options in your shop?
Absolutely. Whether your pet thrives on a grain-free diet or prefers wholesome grains like brown rice, our Holistic Choice recipes and partner brands cover both options, making it simple to shop based on your pet’s needs.
Do you offer healthy treats for cats?
Yes! The Pet Pantry carries a selection of nutritious, cat-approved treats made without fillers or harmful additives—perfect for rewarding your cat while supporting their overall health.
Does Holistic Choice have a better recall record than national brands?
Yes! Holistic Choice has a spotless recall record—something we’re very proud of. Every batch is carefully tested before it reaches your door to guarantee safety and nutrition. Unlike big brands like Purina or Iams, which have faced multiple recalls, Holistic Choice gives you peace of mind and consistent, reliable quality in every bowl.
Does The Pet Pantry offer a guarantee for the Holistic Choice food?
We stand by our 100% satisfaction guarantee—if you’re not happy, we’ll make it right or refund your purchase. No hassles, no small print.
How is Holistic Choice pet food made?
Holistic Choice is made with care from start to finish. We start by selecting human-quality proteins, wholesome grains, and farm-fresh fruits and vegetables, all sourced in the USA. Each recipe is then slow-cooked in small batches at lower temperatures to preserve nutrients, flavor, and digestibility. Finally, every batch is tested for safety and quality before it ever reaches your pet’s bowl. This makes a nutrient-dense food that supports better digestion, a stronger immune system, shiny coats, and long-term vitality.
Is Holistic Choice better for picky eaters or pets with sensitivities than big brands?
Yes! Since Holistic Choice is made without corn, wheat, soy, or by-products, it’s a great fit for picky eaters, allergy-prone pets, and sensitive stomachs. And with both grain-inclusive and grain-free recipes, you’ve got the flexibility to choose the diet that best supports your pet’s unique needs.
Is The Pet Pantry locally owned?
Yes, we’ve been locally owned and operated in North Carolina for nearly 20 years, and we’re proud to support our community with personalized service
Is your packaging BPA-free?
Yes. All Holistic Choice products are BPA-free.
Should I add vitamins or other supplements on top of their daily food?
For normally healthy pets a supplement/vitamin is not necessary when feeding Holistic Choice foods. If your pet has a specific health issue that needs to be addressed, supplements/vitamins may be a good option to consider. Always consult with your pet's veterinarian for more information on supplements and vitamins.
What health benefits can I expect from feeding Holistic Choice?
Pet parents report shinier coats, healthier skin, stronger immune systems, better digestion, improved stool quality, and more consistent energy after switching to Holistic Choice.
What human foods are safe to add to my dog’s food?
Some fresh, whole foods can be a healthy addition to your dog’s diet in moderation. Safe options include: Lean proteins like plain cooked chicken, turkey, or salmon (no seasoning, bones, or skin). Vegetables such as carrots, green beans, pumpkin, or broccoli. Fruits like blueberries, apple slices (without seeds), or bananas. Plain grains like rice or oatmeal (cooked and unseasoned). Healthy extras such as a spoonful of plain pumpkin purée or plain yogurt (no added sugar or artificial sweeteners).
What human foods should I not feed to my dog?
Some foods and additives that are safe for humans can be harmful—or even dangerous—for dogs. Ingredients to avoid include:Chocolate & caffeine – can be toxic to the nervous system and heart. Grapes & raisins – may cause kidney failure. Onions, garlic, chives – damage red blood cells and can cause anemia. Xylitol (artificial sweetener) – found in sugar-free gum, peanut butter, and baked goods; can cause dangerous drops in blood sugar. Alcohol & raw yeast dough – harmful to the liver and digestive system. High-fat or heavily seasoned foods – can upset digestion and may trigger pancreatitis. By-products, artificial colors, and preservatives – offer no nutritional value and may be harsh on sensitive systems. If you feel unsure about a particular food, it is recommended to err on the side of caution and not give the food to your pet.
What is Holistic Choice pet food?
Holistic Choice is our super-premium pet food, made with human-quality ingredients and slow-cooked in small batches to lock in nutrients. Every recipe is thoughtfully crafted to deliver balanced, wholesome nutrition for both dogs and cats.
What makes Holistic Choice different from other pet foods?
Holistic Choice is our own exclusive brand, handcrafted in small batches and slow-cooked at low temperatures right here in the USA. We use only human-grade ingredients with no by-products, fillers, GMOs, or artificial additives—just real, wholesome nutrition you can feel good about. Pets thrive on our recipes, and their humans love the noticeable difference in energy, digestion, skin, coat and overall vitality
What makes slow-cooking at lower temperatures better?
Slow-cooking at lower temperatures helps preserve the natural nutrients, flavors, and integrity of each ingredient. Unlike high-heat methods that can break down proteins and vitamins, our gentle process locks in nutrition so your pet gets the full benefits of wholesome, real-food ingredients. It also enhances digestibility and taste, making every meal both healthier and more enjoyable for your pet.
Where are Holistic Choice foods made and where do you source ingredients from?
All of our Holistic Choice foods are proudly made in the USA. Our ingredients are carefully sourced from trusted U.S. farmers and suppliers—never overseas. That means you can trust that every bowl is filled with safe, high-quality, wholesome ingredients
Will my picky eater actually eat it?
Absolutely. We hear it all the time—bowls licked clean! With multiple flavors and proteins to choose from, even the pickiest eaters usually find their favorite. We offer very generous free samples and we’ll work with you to find a recipe they love.
Your Pets' Information*
This field is required.
This field is required.
Choose Gift*
- Toy
- Treat